Wolfram Alpha is NOT a Google-Killer!
This is one issue that one poorly written Techcrunch article in particular brought up - people seem to think that Wolfram Alpha is made to compete with web search engines like Google. In reality, this kind of comparison is like saying that Wikipedia is trying to shut down Google - it just doesn’t make sense! Wolfram Alpha does focus more on a search bar than most wiki sites, but it’s not made for finding web pages - it simple uses curated data to answer questions, plain and simple.
Wolfram Alpha Homepage
I can see how the whole Google-killer title developed - Wolfram Alpha’s homepage even looks like Google in design. Google’s brand new charts for a few types of information (released during the Wolfram Alpha webcast, no less) also are bordering it’s functionality. However, the people who have tried the product (or at least watched the webcast) agree that it has a wide range of factual data and is capable of making computations based on this data. This is a functionality different from any keyword-based searching and something unseen so far (most notable attempt being Cyc and OpenCyc); as a result we have no baseline to compare it to or a service to be one-upped.
One thing that would really clear up these arguments, though, would be a proper demo from Wolfram - not a long webcast or a leaked screenshot, but a proper 2-3 minute video just demoing its capabilities. Because of the academic presentation of Wolfram Alpha so far, its descriptive hasn’t reached that wide an audience - a more accessible video would make much more of an impact. The point is mute, of course, since they’re opening it for public use in the next month; all the same it would be nice to get one proper preview.
With that, I rest my case. I’m sure that, if it lives up to its claims, it will be an amazing academic resource and completely irrelevant to general Googling. I think that it’s got a good chance of fulfilling its claims too, considering that it’s the same team (and mind) that created Mathematica - even with a 15-day trial it’s clear the software’s over my head in complexity. So if any team can pull it off, it’s likely Wolfram’s.
